Checklist for Multi-Cluster CI/CD Observability Setup

Multi-cluster CI/CD pipelines are complex, and without proper observability, you risk downtime, bottlenecks, and deployment failures. This guide outlines a practical checklist for setting up observability across clusters, ensuring you can track, monitor, and optimise your workflows efficiently. Here’s what you’ll need:

• Define Goals and Metrics: Identify key objectives like reducing downtime or improving deployment speed. Track metrics such as deployment frequency, error rates, and resource usage.
• Map Your Clusters: Document roles (e.g., build, data, observability planes) and ensure secure connectivity between clusters.
• Install Observability Tools: Use tools like Prometheus for metrics, OpenSearch for logs, and OpenTelemetry for tracing. Automate agent deployment with Helm and DaemonSets.
• Centralise Data: Aggregate logs, metrics, and traces in a dedicated observability cluster for a unified view.
• Set Alerts and Dashboards: Configure alerts for failures and resource issues. Use dashboards to visualise cluster health and performance.
• Secure the Setup: Apply TLS encryption, Kubernetes RBAC, and regular audits to protect sensitive data.

Cost-Efficient Multi-Cluster Monitoring with Prometheus, Grafana & Linkerd - Carolin Dohmen, BWI

Set Observability Goals and Key Metrics

Before diving into tools and configurations, it's important to define what success looks like for your multi-cluster CI/CD observability. Without clear objectives and measurable targets, even the most advanced monitoring setups can fall short. A solid understanding of your goals helps you choose the right metrics and tools, which we'll explore in the sections ahead.

Set Clear Observability Objectives

Your observability goals should tackle the major challenges of managing multi-cluster environments. For instance, reducing downtime is crucial to minimise operational disruptions, while improving pipeline visibility helps identify bottlenecks more quickly.

Proactive monitoring is another game-changer. Instead of rushing to fix problems after they've impacted users, you can catch and address issues before they escalate. A great example of this comes from a tech startup that slashed its deployment time from 6 hours to just 20 minutes by combining a DevOps overhaul with robust monitoring tools [1].

By addressing infrastructure issues upfront, developers can focus on building features that add value to the business - a critical edge in competitive markets. Once your objectives are clear, the next step is to identify metrics that reflect progress towards those goals.

Choose Key Metrics and KPIs

The metrics you track will dictate how well you measure progress. Deployment frequency, for example, shows how often teams deliver updates to users. A higher frequency often signals a more mature and dependable pipeline. Similarly, build success rates provide a quick snapshot of code quality and infrastructure health. A sudden drop in this metric across multiple clusters might point to systemic issues that need immediate attention. Pairing this with error rate tracking can help you pinpoint whether the root cause lies in the code or the infrastructure.

Resource usage metrics - like CPU, memory, and storage consumption - are particularly important for managing costs in multi-cluster setups. Keeping a close eye on these can help avoid unnecessary cloud expenses caused by inefficient resource allocation.

Other useful metrics include pipeline duration and rollback frequency. Shorter pipeline times combined with fewer rollbacks often indicate a well-optimised and reliable process. On the flip side, frequent rollbacks might signal deeper issues with quality or testing. According to industry data, organisations that adopt comprehensive monitoring solutions often achieve up to 75% faster deployments and reduce errors by as much as 90% in their CI/CD workflows [1].

Match SLAs and SLOs

Your observability efforts should align with the service level commitments you've made to customers and internal teams. Service Level Agreements (SLAs) are your contractual promises - like guaranteeing 99.9% uptime. Your monitoring system must track and alert you to any events that could jeopardise these commitments.

Service Level Objectives (SLOs), on the other hand, are internal performance targets that support your SLAs while factoring in operational realities. For instance, you might aim for 95% of deployments to complete within 10 minutes, which helps maintain a broader availability goal.

Each metric should be tied to its relevant SLA or SLO. For example, if your SLA guarantees response times under 200 milliseconds, your monitoring system must track latency across all clusters and issue alerts as thresholds are approached.

Regularly reviewing these metric-to-SLA alignments is essential, particularly as requirements evolve. For UK-based organisations, compliance with regulations like GDPR is often a key consideration. This means observability objectives must also include monitoring data handling and retention practices.

Metrics tied to SLAs should trigger immediate alerts and responses, while supporting metrics provide additional context for long-term improvements. This approach helps prevent alert fatigue and ensures that critical issues get the attention they deserve. Together, these metrics and goals form the backbone of reliable multi-cluster operations.

If aligning metrics with SLAs and SLOs feels overwhelming, consulting firms like Hokstad Consulting can provide expert guidance. They specialise in streamlining DevOps workflows and crafting observability strategies that balance business goals with operational costs.

Prepare Multi-Cluster Environments

Getting clusters ready for observability requires thoughtful preparation. Without a structured approach, even the most advanced monitoring tools may struggle to provide a unified view across a multi-cluster setup.

Map Cluster Roles and Connections

Start by compiling a detailed inventory of every Kubernetes cluster involved in your CI/CD workflow. Each cluster has a specific role, and understanding these roles is key to achieving effective observability. For instance:

• Build Plane: Handles CI pipeline execution and image building, generating logs and metrics tied to the build process.
• Data Plane: Manages application deployment and runtime, producing both application and infrastructure logs.
• Observability Plane: Serves as the central hub for monitoring and logging, aggregating and visualising data from all clusters.

To spot potential bottlenecks, document the relationships between clusters using clear diagrams. Validate network connectivity early by testing secure communication between clusters and the observability plane. For example, when setting up FluentBit to send logs from build and data plane clusters to the observability plane, ensure endpoints like openchoreo-op-control-plane:30920 are accessible from all source clusters [2]. Use network scanning tools to confirm connectivity before deploying agents.

Once clusters are mapped, confirm secure connectivity and permissions to ensure seamless observability.

Check Access and Permissions

After mapping, focus on securing access and verifying inter-cluster permissions. Strong access controls are essential for maintaining security in multi-cluster observability setups. Create dedicated service accounts for observability agents in each cluster, limiting their permissions strictly to what’s required for data collection and forwarding. Avoid granting broad administrative access, as this increases the risk of security vulnerabilities.

Leverage Kubernetes RBAC (Role-Based Access Control) to assign these service accounts to specific cluster roles [3]. For instance, a service account that can read metrics and logs but cannot modify cluster resources ensures adherence to the principle of least privilege, safeguarding your infrastructure while enabling agents to function effectively.

To secure inter-cluster communications, implement certificate-based authentication with cert-manager [3]. Ensure all production endpoints use TLS and establish a regular certificate rotation schedule to maintain security.

Fragmented visibility can delay CI/CD issue resolution, and poor access controls may escalate these delays into security risks. Regularly auditing service account permissions helps prevent privilege escalation and ensures compliance with security policies.

It’s also worth noting that observability plane components like OpenSearch pods may take several minutes to initialise properly [2]. During this time, confirm that all components reach a Ready status before moving forward with cross-cluster configurations. Automate these checks using kubectl wait commands with appropriate timeouts.

Namespace isolation further enhances organisation and security. By creating separate namespaces - such as openchoreo-observability-plane, openchoreo-build-plane, and openchoreo-data-plane - you can manage observability components independently from application workloads. This approach simplifies applying tailored security policies and resource quotas [2].

Establishing robust access controls lays a solid foundation for observability, aligning with your operational goals. For organisations managing complex multi-cluster environments, this preparation phase can feel daunting. Hokstad Consulting offers expert guidance in DevOps transformation, helping businesses map cluster roles, strengthen network security, and fine-tune access controls. Their tailored strategies can streamline observability setups, reducing operational overhead while improving deployment efficiency.

Install and Configure Observability Tools

Now that your clusters are mapped, permissions secured, and observability goals set, it's time to focus on selecting and deploying the right tools. The success of monitoring in a multi-cluster CI/CD environment hinges on tools that can handle distributed data collection while maintaining centralised visibility.

Select the Right Tools

Choosing observability tools for multi-cluster environments requires careful thought. The tools must support multi-cluster data aggregation, integrate with your existing CI/CD platforms, and scale with your infrastructure. These factors ensure seamless data collection and analysis across distributed systems.

A solid observability stack often includes the following:

• Prometheus: Known for its metrics collection capabilities, Prometheus supports federation and offers a wide range of exporters.
• Grafana: Provides unified dashboards and alerting features, making it ideal for visualising metrics.
• OpenSearch: Handles log storage and analytics, offering scalability and compatibility with Kibana interfaces.
• OpenTelemetry: A growing favourite for distributed tracing and improving interoperability in multi-cluster setups.

When evaluating tools, pay close attention to security features. Tools should support TLS encryption for data in transit and integrate with Kubernetes RBAC for access control. Isolating observability components in dedicated namespaces further strengthens your security setup.

Start small by testing tool compatibility with a simple integration before scaling up. OpenTelemetry, for example, is increasingly adopted due to its standardised approach, making it a strong choice for long-term strategies in multi-cluster environments.

Deploy Observability Agents

Deploying agents across multiple clusters is a critical step, and automation is your best friend here. Helm charts and operators simplify the installation process, enabling consistent deployment of agents like Prometheus exporters and Fluent Bit across clusters.

A practical example comes from OpenChoreo's October 2023 multi-cluster observability setup. They used a dedicated observability plane cluster with OpenSearch for log storage and OpenSearch Dashboard for visualisation. Fluent Bit agents were deployed on both build and data plane clusters to centralise logs, with Helm automation ensuring smooth deployment.

To ensure full visibility, deploy agents as DaemonSets across all nodes. Configure Fluent Bit agents with clear endpoints for central log collection and maintain uniform configurations across clusters. Centralised management tools can help propagate updates and automate readiness checks, reducing errors and downtime.

Security should remain a priority. Assign dedicated service accounts to each agent with minimal permissions required for their tasks. When initialising agents, especially complex components like OpenSearch pods, use kubectl wait commands with appropriate timeouts to avoid connectivity issues that could disrupt your observability setup.

Once your agents are deployed and secured, the next step involves integrating these tools with your CI/CD platforms for a seamless monitoring pipeline.

Connect with CI/CD Platforms

With observability agents in place, linking them to your CI/CD platforms provides a complete view of your pipeline. While integration specifics vary by platform, the general principles apply to tools like GitLab, Jenkins, and ArgoCD.

Configure your CI/CD tools to send logs, metrics, and traces to the observability stack. Many platforms offer built-in integrations or plugins to simplify this process. For example, GitLab and ArgoCD provide robust APIs and webhook support to enable seamless data flow to monitoring dashboards.

Set up webhooks in your CI/CD platforms to trigger alerts for key events such as build starts, deployment completions, or failures. This real-time data flow ensures you have immediate insights into pipeline health and performance.

Once data is flowing, create dashboards to visualise pipeline health, build status, and deployment metrics across all clusters. These dashboards should correlate CI/CD events with infrastructure metrics, offering valuable context for troubleshooting and optimisation.

The benefits of integrating observability with CI/CD go beyond monitoring. Organisations that adopt automated CI/CD pipelines with integrated monitoring often see up to 75% faster deployments and a 90% reduction in errors [1]. These improvements come from minimising manual bottlenecks and reducing human error.

Alerting should cover the entire CI/CD system rather than focusing on individual clusters. Alerts for pipeline failures, deployment anomalies, and performance issues across multi-cluster environments help catch problems early and reduce resolution times.

For organisations managing complex multi-cluster CI/CD workflows, integration can be challenging. With over 60% of enterprises now operating multi-cluster Kubernetes environments, observability remains a top operational challenge [4]. Hokstad Consulting offers expertise in streamlining these integrations, helping you optimise your observability tools while reducing operational overhead and improving deployment cycles.

Configure Logging, Metrics, and Tracing

With your observability tools deployed, the next step is to set up logging, metrics, and tracing. These elements are essential for achieving full visibility into your multi-cluster CI/CD workflows, helping you identify issues faster and optimise performance.

Set Up Centralised Logging

Centralised logging is a cornerstone of multi-cluster observability. It consolidates logs from pipeline jobs, clusters, and applications into one searchable interface. To get started, deploy a log aggregation tool like OpenSearch or Elasticsearch in a dedicated observability cluster. This approach keeps your monitoring infrastructure separate from production workloads while serving as the central repository for log data. Use log shippers like Fluent Bit in each cluster to send logs to the central backend.

To ensure secure and reliable log transfer, configure TLS encryption and set up network policies that allow observability agents to communicate with the central backend. After making configuration changes, restart the agents to apply the updates.

Gather logs from several sources, including pipeline jobs (covering build, test, and deployment stages), Kubernetes system components, and application services. Tag logs with identifiers such as cluster names, namespaces, and application labels. This tagging makes it easier to filter and correlate events using dashboards in tools like OpenSearch Dashboard or Kibana.

Track Key Metrics

Metrics provide a quantitative view of how your multi-cluster CI/CD system is performing, from resource usage to deployment outcomes. The challenge lies in standardising metrics across clusters while accounting for the unique characteristics of each environment.

Set up your clusters and pipelines to track metrics such as CPU, memory, and storage usage, as well as deployment performance indicators like duration, success rates, and failure rates. Popular tools like Prometheus, Datadog, and Grafana are excellent for collecting and visualising these metrics in distributed setups.

Research from Datadog highlights the benefits of comprehensive monitoring, showing that organisations with extensive coverage across their CI/CD systems experience faster issue resolution and fewer overlooked problems [5]. Configure system-wide monitors and alerts rather than focusing only on individual clusters. Automated alerts based on key metrics and log patterns can help minimise downtime and enhance system reliability.

For example, one startup reduced deployment time from six hours to just 20 minutes, while an e-commerce company improved performance by 50% and cut costs by 30% [1].

These metrics align with the broader goals of your observability strategy, ensuring your system operates smoothly.

Enable Distributed Tracing

Distributed tracing offers a detailed, end-to-end view of requests and processes as they move through multiple clusters. It’s especially useful for diagnosing issues that span cluster boundaries or pinpointing performance bottlenecks in complex deployments.

Deploy tracing agents such as the OpenTelemetry Collector in each cluster and configure them to send trace data to a central backend like Jaeger or Tempo. This setup provides a unified view of all requests and processes. Instrument your CI/CD jobs and applications to generate trace spans that capture key operations and their relationships.

To protect your tracing data, use TLS encryption for secure transmission, restrict access to endpoints with network policies and authentication, and redact sensitive information. By correlating logs, metrics, and traces with standardised labels and integrated observability platforms, you can turn scattered data into actionable insights. This unified approach ties back to the overarching observability framework.

For organisations managing complex multi-cluster environments, implementing a robust observability strategy can be technically demanding. Hokstad Consulting provides expertise in DevOps transformation and observability solutions, helping teams adopt best practices for logging, metrics, and tracing while optimising costs and deployment processes.

Set Up Monitoring, Alerting, and Security

Once your logging, metrics, and tracing systems are in place, the next step is to establish monitoring, alerting, and solid security measures. These steps help turn raw data into actionable insights while safeguarding sensitive information.

Create Alerts and Dashboards

With data flowing through your system, it's time to convert it into meaningful alerts and visual insights. Set up targeted alerts for critical failure points in your multi-cluster CI/CD pipeline, such as build failures, deployment errors, resource shortages, or security threats. Ensure notifications are routed to the right teams - via Slack, email, or other tools - so they can respond promptly. For instance, deployment issues should go directly to the DevOps team, while resource exhaustion alerts might involve both infrastructure and development teams [5].

To prioritise incidents effectively, assign severity levels to your alerts. Critical issues, such as total pipeline failures, demand immediate attention, whereas lower-priority alerts, like elevated response times, can be addressed during regular working hours. Reduce alert fatigue by implementing deduplication and suppressing alerts during maintenance windows [5].

Dashboards are equally essential. They provide a visual overview of cluster health, deployment success rates, error trends, resource usage, and latency. Tools like Grafana and OpenSearch Dashboards are particularly useful for managing data across multiple clusters [2][6].

Customise dashboards for different teams. Developers often need detailed insights into application performance and deployment statuses, while site reliability engineers benefit from broader metrics and cross-cluster correlations. Include drill-down features, allowing teams to move from high-level overviews to detailed root cause analysis quickly [6].

For example, in 2023, OpenChoreo users built an observability plane using OpenSearch and dashboards to monitor multi-cluster CI/CD pipelines. Logs were forwarded in real-time using FluentBit agents deployed across clusters. However, they initially overlooked encrypting data in transit, which posed a security risk in production environments [2].

Apply Security Best Practices

Once your alerts and dashboards are in place, focus on securing these systems to protect sensitive data and maintain compliance across clusters. Observability data often contains critical information about your infrastructure, applications, and business processes, making robust security essential.

TLS encryption is a must, especially for inter-cluster communications in production. Use tools like cert-manager to automate the generation and renewal of certificates. Configure observability agents, such as FluentBit and OpenTelemetry Collector, to use these certificates for all connections [2][3].

Implement RBAC (Role-Based Access Control) in your observability platforms. Use minimal-privilege service accounts and tightly scoped cluster roles to limit access to sensitive data [3].

Centralise authentication by integrating single sign-on (SSO) or LDAP with your observability dashboards. This approach simplifies user management and ensures consistent access control as your team grows. Additionally, enable audit logging to track who accesses what data and when, creating a transparent activity trail [3].

Regular audits are crucial to maintaining security over time. Schedule reviews of RBAC policies, certificate validity, network configurations, and observability tool settings. Use automated tools to identify misconfigurations, expired certificates, or unauthorised access attempts. Frameworks like the CIS Kubernetes Benchmarks can serve as helpful references for your audits [3].

By combining robust monitoring with these security measures, you can create a reliable and secure multi-cluster observability framework.

For organisations managing complex multi-cluster setups, implementing these practices can be both technically demanding and resource-intensive. Hokstad Consulting specialises in DevOps transformation and observability solutions, assisting UK businesses in building scalable, secure monitoring systems while optimising costs and deployment processes. Their services include designing observability architectures, automating security tools, and ensuring compliance in challenging environments.

Troubleshooting and Ongoing Improvement

Once you've established a solid observability framework, the next step is tackling challenges as they arise and refining your approach over time. Even the best multi-cluster observability setups will encounter hurdles. The key is to stay proactive, identify issues early, and adjust your strategy as needed.

Fix Common Problems

Some of the most frequent issues include fragmented visibility, tool overload, and reactive troubleshooting. These can all disrupt deployment reliability across clusters.

Fragmented visibility happens when you can't get a full picture of your pipeline's health across all clusters. This often shows up as inconsistent or missing data from specific clusters, making it harder to pinpoint the root cause of issues. Teams typically notice this when critical failures go undetected in certain environments, or when incident response is delayed because vital information is scattered across disconnected systems [4].

To address this, consolidate logs and metrics from all clusters into a single platform. For example, deploy OpenTelemetry Collectors in each cluster and send the data to a centralised collector for a unified view. Regularly test data flow from each cluster to ensure consistent visibility [3].

Tool sprawl is another common challenge. It occurs when teams rely on too many different tools, forcing them to jump between dashboards to connect logs, metrics, and traces. This not only slows down incident response but also increases the chance of missing critical links between data sources. Simplify your workflows by standardising on a small, integrated set of observability tools. Platforms like Grafana can handle multiple data types, streamlining your observability processes. Integrating these tools with CI/CD pipelines and retiring redundant solutions can also reduce operational overhead [5][6].

Reactive troubleshooting is when teams only address problems after they happen, often due to a lack of real-time monitoring or predictive tools. This approach can lead to extended downtimes and unhappy users. Shift to a proactive approach by setting up real-time alerts, predictive analytics, and automated monitoring. Dashboards tracking metrics like build times, error rates, and deployment frequency can help spot anomalies early. You might also explore machine learning-based tools for anomaly detection or trend analysis to further enhance your monitoring capabilities [7].

Take, for example, Datadog's platform engineering team at a UK fintech company. In May 2023, they reduced pipeline downtime by 38% over three months by automating monitors for orphaned Kubernetes pods and integrating Slack notifications for their CI reliability teams. They also cut their mean time to resolution (MTTR) for CI/CD incidents by 22% through regular reviews of alert coverage and incident response processes [5].

When dealing with data collection and forwarding issues, it's essential to check inter-cluster connectivity, verify observability agent configurations (like FluentBit or OpenTelemetry Collector), and ensure authentication and TLS encryption are correctly set up. After making configuration changes, restart the observability agents and monitor their logs for errors to quickly identify and resolve misconfigurations [2].

Once immediate issues are resolved, focus on regular reviews to ensure lasting improvements.

Improve Through Regular Reviews

Consistent evaluation is critical for refining your observability setup. Schedule quarterly reviews to assess areas like coverage, alert accuracy, and incident response performance [7]. These reviews should focus on which clusters and pipelines are monitored, the effectiveness of alerts, and how quickly incidents are resolved.

Involve teams across development, operations, and security to gather feedback on application visibility, infrastructure monitoring, and compliance. Here's an example of how you can structure your reviews:

Track key metrics like alert frequency, mean time to detect (MTTD), MTTR, and overall monitoring coverage. Pay attention to how many clusters have complete observability integration and how quickly new clusters are onboarded. Collect qualitative feedback from incident responders to provide context for the numbers.

Action items from these reviews should be prioritised and tracked in subsequent cycles to ensure improvements are implemented. This approach ensures that lessons learned translate into practical upgrades to your observability setup.

Don't overlook security while refining your processes. Use TLS encryption for data in transit, role-based access control (RBAC) for observability agents, and regularly rotate credentials and certificates. Include security checks in your regular assessments to avoid exposing sensitive data or weakening your cluster defences [2].

For organisations managing complex multi-cluster environments, these troubleshooting and improvement practices can be challenging to implement. Companies like Hokstad Consulting specialise in optimising DevOps workflows, cloud infrastructure, and observability tools. Their expertise helps UK businesses improve deployment reliability and reduce incident response times.

Conclusion

Achieving effective multi-cluster observability requires a structured approach, starting with defining clear objectives and metrics, followed by mapping your cluster architecture, and then deploying unified observability tools. Finally, you need to establish centralised logging, metrics, and tracing. These components come together to provide a complete picture of your distributed systems.

At the core of a successful observability setup are well-defined objectives and metrics. Once these are in place, selecting and configuring the right tools becomes critical to effectively correlate events across multiple clusters.

Continuous monitoring and fine-tuning play a key role in ensuring system reliability and performance. Research shows that organisations with mature observability practices resolve incidents up to 60% faster and experience 30% fewer deployment failures compared to those relying on ad hoc monitoring [5]. This not only reduces downtime but also enhances the user experience significantly.

The impact goes beyond technical improvements. For instance, one organisation reported a 95% reduction in infrastructure-related downtime after adopting a systematic observability strategy [1].

To secure your observability data, make sure to integrate measures like TLS encryption, Role-Based Access Control (RBAC), and regular credential rotation.

It’s important to view observability as a continuous process rather than a one-time setup. Regular reviews - ideally on a quarterly basis - can help identify gaps, refine alert thresholds, and adjust to changes in your infrastructure. Investing in the right observability practices leads to better system reliability, quicker incident resolution, and stronger overall business results.

For UK organisations tackling these challenges, collaborating with experts like Hokstad Consulting can simplify the implementation process. Their expertise in optimising DevOps workflows and managing cloud infrastructure can help ensure long-term success.

FAQs